A thought about Corruption
The corruption is a cancerous
deadly decease that affected the society, since human existence. It is a short cut to amaze money for some,
and it is a short cut to get the things done for another. Actually it is a mutually accepted
arrangement where the giver and receiver is responsible. However many times the givers role is
underestimated and focus is given to the receiver and the effort to curb
corruption is always focused at the receiver. It is just like to divert the
flow of water from lower plain to upper.
Some people are interested in ending corruption, but involved in the
business of talking and putting efforts to stop corruption as a ritual,
knowingly well that it cannot be stopped.
I am prompted to pen this, when
the report seen in HINDU Daily, about an
order of Tamilnadu. The order mandates
prior permission of the government for
an enquiry about corruption charges against any state government employee
keeping the state vigilance machinery into a bye stander. It is a setback for those who dream against corruption
and who complaint lack of integrity in
public services. Interestingly, even the
opposition has not raised a single voice of protest. Those who have stayed in Tamilnadu will
vouchsafe the level of massive corruption at various level and most of the
major political parties are at the receiving end of massive corruption when they
are in power. Hence this order gives an
umbrella of protection to lower level
employees at government level as I
understand. It does not mean that Kerala
is free from corruption. But I had a
false proud that the Dravidian(I mean south Indian) level of corruption is much
less in level in quantum compared to other states as I experienced. Of course I agree that Corruption is
corruption and integrity cannot be measured
in scale. During my childhood
days, I had heard that the corruption at Cochin state is much less than in
Travancore Stat; Ara kallan and Mukka
Kallan (Half thief, and three fourth thief)
The only way to end corruption is
to nib it in the bud. Giving corruption be made a criminal offence. I doubt, even
Anna Hazard, or Kejriwal might not have thought on these lines. Then who will bell the cat is the
question. Then can we define small level
corruption and large scale corruption and can corruption at certain level can
be permit?. Earlier times, when the post
man brings money order used to be paid bakshish/chay pani karcha. So can we consider the money paid through the
agents of RTO office, Registry Office or Village office, or the amount paid to
a TTE for accommodating a birth be
treated as Chay pani karcha.
I am mused to look into the
corruption at my level as giver or receiver.
The small amount paid to Railway employee to accommodate a birth,
the small amount of Rs.10/- paid at Madras Railway Reservation Counter, just to
know whether onward reservation is ok or not is not a bribe as far as I was
concerned at that time. The timely help
was much bigger than the amount paid.
Then smaller or bigger paid many times at various govt offices. I found that the level of corruption at
Jharkhand is much higher than that of Kerala.
But there is a difference experienced people say. At Jharkhand every thing is fixed and
moderated and you pay it, work will be done promptly and correctly. But in kerala, you pay it, and no guarantee
work will be done and that too correctly.
We bof corruption is very low and there are large number of people who is not associated with corruption.
Later I understood that giving
and receiving bribe is also a skill. All
can not do it. I had an occasion to get
a work done at Utkal University , Bhubaneshwar.
The name in the certificate was misspelt. I wanted to correct it. It was the time that we got married. So we preferred our destination of honeymoon
as Bhubaneswhar. 7 days we stayed at
Bhubaneshwar. The university staff was
not corrupt, but no work will be done.
Very lazy people. On the 7th
day, a message was sent through a peon that I am prepared to give some money as
gift. The officer responsible was
pleasantly surprised and the work was done at great speed. Then how to give the money. He was afraid and me too. Ultimately money was paid in the toilet. Then he was particular that other staff
should not know about it. So to have a
cover up operation, I am to distribute cool drinks and snacks to all the staff and he has to convey to his
staff that the work was done speedily as a gesture of cool drink business much
before. She has every reason to
complaint that the honey moon was enjoyed in the dusty corridors of University. In a cinema theatre at Jharkhand, the movie
house was houseful. Had it been in
Kerala, no question of negotiation or talking to the Manager. Upon payment of Rs.50 per ticket extra,
chairs were provided in the projector room and tea/snacks at the time of
interval. By any standard, I do not
agree that the Rs.50 extra is a bribe.
A driver at Ernakulam Zonal
Office Received a lump sum money for
getting the registration of my car got changed to Kerala from Bhopal. Later it is brought to my notice that the
actual amount involved is much lesser than what I have paid. I really don’t know who cheated whom. The RTO people on the driver or the driver on
me. I suppose this will not come under
corruption.
I had a scooter accident while at
North Parur. A small boy was hurt and his
leg had an hairline crack. Using my
connection as the Branch Manager, I could thrash it out, but I was cautioned
that the parents of the boy could create problem any time. At that time I observed that My driving
licence had expired. Now to be on safer
side, I got a licence back dated from Madras paying Rs.2000. I am sure it is really a bribe.
A work is pending with a
government office for the last one year.
An outright honest officer will not receive any bribe nor he can get the
work done by his subordinate. Is it wrong that I prefer an officer who receive
a paltry amount and get the work done or the inefficient outright honest
officer.
For valuation of my newly
constructed house and fixing the tax, I
was after the Panchayat staff with money.
Somebody made me to believe that if money is not paid, tax will be at a very higher slab. I was very upset that he is not ready to
receive any money. All he told was that
it is not necessary. I was little bit
upset that I could not make him receive the money for a lesser amount of tax
slab. But I noticed that the tax slab
was quite reasonable.
Before concluding, I feel I shall
share a few occasions that I have received bribe by way of kind, money or
service.
I remember Mr. Mohanan, a
contractor customer of my branch helped me to come out of a traffic police
case. In another occasion he supplied a
few loads of granite metal to our nearby temple from his quary with out
receiving money. I also remember the
face of Mr. Esthapanose, an RTO borrower
who kept a few bags of vegetables, banana chips and ripe banana in the
occasion of Onam. He has not brought it
in the previous Onam season and the next season too. So it can be treated as a gratification of
the loan sanctioned. But I could not
refuse the gratification and ask him to
take it back considering his hurt feeling, if I do so. The quantum was big enough to consume for a
small family of mine and my neighbours helped me in this regard. I also enjoyed the fruit jucie, cake and jam
bottles brought by one of the customer during the Christmas season. We were
more allured over the cane made beautiful basket which contained the gift than
the gift itself. The basket is still
with me. I also know that a bookshelf I
have purchased, while I was at Ernakulam branch was much under invoiced than
the actual price. What about the customer who brings Alphonse mangoes every
year?
In some part of the country,
during the deevali season sweets and dry fruits are gifted in abundance. My family do not use sweet and how much quantity of dry
fruit we can consume. So it was
liberally distributed among staff. They
were not so much enthusiastic to
receive such packets, because they were also gifted. On one occasion, I had distributed such a
packet to one of my staff. Next day he
came with a guilty conscious feeling and told me that there was one gold coin
in the packet. He just could not
believe, when I told him that gold coin belongs to him, since I have gifted to
him. I wrote a DO letter to that
customer thanking him and advising him not to repeat such practice as the
receiver will expect better gift next time.
The letter was written without any expectation of any change in the
practice, but for my satisfaction. My
refusal of some such gift have at times annoyed the giver too. He felt, he is belittled.
I had a customer banking with our
bank since 1978 and I joined the bank in 1979.
He used to comment jokingly that he is senior to me. Once when I was out of office, he put a
packet in my drawer and told my sub staff to remind me. It was a cover
containing 20 thousand rupee note. It
was a bakshish or speed money lovingly given by the customer for sanctioning
one of his limit with record time never happened in his experience. Eventhough the credit goes to the then Zonal manager for the speedy disposal of the
proposal, I enjoyed the credit. But
handling the cash was difficult for me.
Crediting back the amount to his Cash credit account, or sending the
money to him was options left out.
Instead, I preferred to donate
this money to an Orphanage in his name. The borrower was not aware of it till
such time the same orphanage people approached him for further donation.
The borrower though not interested in my style of philanthropy,
sincerely appreciated my action.
A few more incident I may have
left out as it may hurt others feelings.
If a borrower customer take money
from you as a personal loan and he do not pay us back. Such incident had happened to me too. Shall we call it reverse corruption like
reverse mortgage.
All said and done, me also
received and paid bribe or part of corruption. Yet I dream of a society with
less corruption. I was talking of
corruption of my reach or knowledge. The
story of corruption of lacs and
thousands of crores coming daily in the newspaper is beyond my reach. Even these type of small type of corruption
could be controlled, the life will improve vastly. I again earnestly feel that the corruption to
be discouraged at the giver level and strict legislation and punishment to be given to the giver. Any takers please?. Let us join hands together and share the idea
first and supplement with your innovative ideas. I am looking forward for your
response.